The historic Oak Park townhouse at 204 Forest Avenue is now on the market. This Queen Anne Victorian sits across from Austin Gardens and combines preserved 19th-century detail with modern updates. Listed at $800,000, it offers both history and practicality for today’s buyers.
Architectural and historical significance
Built in 1891 by architect William J. Van Keuren, the home is one of the Emerson Ingalls Row Houses. Van Keuren, who lived in Oak Park, also designed several notable landmarks. His works include the Cicero Fire House No. 2—now the Oak Park River Forest Museum—and the Niles block on Marion and South Boulevard.
These Forest Avenue row houses remain largely unchanged since their construction. With original brickwork, front porches, and Victorian craftsmanship, they continue to draw attention from both locals and visitors. Inside, authentic features like pocket doors, art glass, and Trent tile fireplaces highlight the home’s lasting character.
A home filled with character and love
Current owner Tara Zinger has lived here for 13 years. She recalls buying the home from a couple with a touching history. The husband left daily love notes for his wife on the walls, and the house radiated warmth. That emotional connection convinced Zinger to make it her own.
During her years here, she raised her children, welcomed students on their bike rides, and even opened her doors to international visitors. She converted the lower level into a short-term rental that earned over $30,000 a year. This income helped pay for college expenses and created lasting friendships with guests from around the world.
Modern updates with timeless charm
Although built in the 19th century, the historic Oak Park townhouse offers many modern features. The lower level has a kitchenette, laundry, and separate entrance. Buyers could keep it as a rental unit or use it for extended family.
The foyer still features original woodwork, including a staircase, built-in bench, and stained glass windows. The front parlor has dentil molding, coved ceilings, and a sweeping park view. The rear parlor includes original pocket doors and a fireplace with Trent tile.
The kitchen carries mid-century style, with Sears & Roebuck cabinets, steel-rimmed counters, and a cheerful yellow Chambers range. The second floor has four bedrooms with transom windows. On the third floor, a modern primary suite features a luxurious bath, kitchenette, laundry, and rooftop deck.
Location in Oak Park’s historic district
The property lies in the Frank Lloyd Wright Prairie School of Architecture Historic District. This location adds both cultural prestige and convenience. Residents are within walking distance of downtown Oak Park’s shops, restaurants, and transit.
For Zinger, Austin Gardens felt like an extension of her home. She described the park as her “living room,” a place that gave the neighborhood constant vibrancy. That same energy now awaits new owners.
A unique opportunity in today’s market
Realtor Ann Keeney of Baird & Warner notes the home’s flexibility. The lower level could continue as a professionally managed rental. It could also serve as private space for in-laws, guests, or an au pair.
With its preserved history, practical upgrades, and sought-after location, the historic Oak Park townhouse at 204 Forest Avenue offers one of the most distinctive opportunities in the Chicago suburbs.
